Sam Hotchkiss
Bio
Samuel Roy Hotchkiss, known to his clients as Sam, is a criminal defense attorney with Coyne, Cundiff and Hillemann, PC in Lake St. Louis, Missouri. Recognized for his trial work and client advocacy, Sam Hotchkiss was honored with the prestigious Atticus Finch Award by the Missouri Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers in 2026. With 13 years of courtroom experience, his entire practice is dedicated to criminal defense in Missouri state courts, representing individuals facing every level of criminal charge—from minor traffic tickets to serious felony homicide cases across Eastern and Mid-Missouri.
Experience & Results
Sam’s career in the legal field began with a life-changing college internship in Los Angeles’ Skid Row. Volunteering at a nonprofit legal clinic serving individuals experiencing homelessness and the loss of government benefits, Sam witnessed how creative problem-solving and legal skills could change lives in moments of acute crisis. Although he never stepped into a courtroom during that internship, the experience shaped his philosophy of law practice. Today, even though he spends almost every day in court, Sam Hotchkiss continues to apply that same creative, client-first problem-solving approach to defending people facing state criminal charges.
What sets Sam apart from other criminal defense attorneys in Missouri is his 360-degree perspective on the legal system. Throughout his 13-year legal career, Sam Hotchkiss has served as a judicial law clerk, a Missouri State Public Defender, and an Assistant Circuit Attorney (prosecutor) in the St. Louis Circuit Attorney’s Office. His work across urban and rural counties in Missouri gives him deep insight into how judges evaluate cases, how prosecutors construct their charges, and where weaknesses in the state’s evidence can be exposed.
Having handled thousands of felony cases across Missouri, Sam is a seasoned litigator who regularly takes complex cases to trial. Rarely does a week go by in which he is not actively cross-examining witnesses or arguing legal motions in front of a judge or jury. Sam maintains strong professional rapport with prosecutors and judges across the region, earning their respect not only through negotiation but through a willingness to aggressively litigate motions and try cases to verdict.
His professional experience includes:
- Thousands of felony and misdemeanor criminal defense cases handled across Eastern and Mid-Missouri
- Extensive jury and bench trial experience in state courts
- Unique background as a judicial law clerk, Missouri State Public Defender, and state prosecutor
- Former Assistant Circuit Attorney in the St. Louis Circuit Attorney’s Office
- Presenter of Continuing Legal Education (CLE) instruction on discovery obligations and courtroom motion practice
Sam’s aggressive motion practice has resulted in countless felony and misdemeanor case dismissals following witness testimony in Missouri courtrooms. This includes successful motions to suppress illegally obtained evidence and motions to dismiss under Missouri’s 911 Good Samaritan Law, which protects individuals from prosecution when seeking medical help for drug overdoses. When trials are necessary to protect his clients' freedom, Sam Hotchkiss delivers decisive results before juries and judges.
His notable case results and trial victories include:
- Full Jury Acquittal – Obtained a complete acquittal at jury trial for a client facing Class B felony Unlawful Use of a Weapon and Armed Criminal Action charges, which carried a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years in state prison upon conviction. The client had previously rejected a 7-year prison plea offer and was convicted only of a lesser offense resulting in a 6-month county jail sentence with probation.
- Felony Reduced to Misdemeanor – Secured a 6-6 hung jury at trial for a client charged with felony drug possession involving drugs found in her purse. After rejecting multiple felony plea offers before trial, the case was resolved shortly after trial with a misdemeanor plea.
- Self-Defense Trial Verdict – Won a Not Guilty verdict in a felony domestic assault trial where the client took the stand and successfully argued self-defense after rejecting a misdemeanor plea offer.
- Bench Trial & Pre-Trial Dismissals – Earned multiple Not Guilty verdicts at bench trials for both felony and misdemeanor charges, as well as pre-trial dismissals through evidentiary motion practice.
Education & Admissions
Sam earned his undergraduate and law degrees with honors, serving on the law journal staff and assisting with legal writing instruction. His academic background and bar admissions include:
- University of Missouri – Kansas City School of Law — Juris Doctor, cum laude (Law Review Staff Member, Teaching Assistant in Legal Writing Program)
- Azusa Pacific University — Bachelor of Arts in Sociology, summa cum laude
- Missouri State Bar — Admitted in 2013
Sam understands that facing criminal allegations is often one of the most frightening and stressful moments in a person's life. He combines rigorous case preparation with clear, straightforward communication, ensuring clients know their options at every stage of the judicial process.
Professional Organizations & Community Involvement
Sam Hotchkiss is actively involved in statewide legal associations and the local community.
His memberships and community ties include:
- The Missouri Bar
- Missouri Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
- Kirk of the Hills Presbyterian Church
Sam is also the recipient of various accolades, including:
- The Atticus Finch Award (Missouri Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, 2026)
- The “Getting in the Way of Injustice” Award (Missouri State Public Defender, 2018)
Whether handling routine traffic matters or defending against major felony charges in Lake St. Louis and throughout Mid-Missouri, Sam Hotchkiss is dedicated to standing beside his clients, protecting their constitutional rights, and securing the best possible outcome for their future.
Bio and Practice Area FAQs for Sam
What should I do if I am facing felony criminal charges in Lake St. Louis or Mid-Missouri?
First, take a deep breath. Facing a felony charge is overwhelming, but you do not have to navigate it alone. Invoke your right to remain silent and avoid discussing your case with police, friends, or on social media until you have an experienced attorney by your side. Reach out to a defense lawyer as soon as possible so we can step in, protect your rights, and begin building a clear strategy for your defense.
How does Missouri’s 911 Good Samaritan Law protect individuals from drug possession charges during a medical emergency?
Missouri’s 911 Good Samaritan Law was enacted to save lives. If you call 911 in good faith to seek medical assistance for someone experiencing a drug overdose or other medical emergency, this law generally protects you—and the person needing help—from being prosecuted for minor drug possession or paraphernalia offenses based on evidence gathered as a result of that call. We frequently use this law in pre-trial motions to get charges dismissed when someone did the right thing by calling for help.
What is the difference between a bench trial and a jury trial in a Missouri state court?
In a jury trial, a group of 12 citizens from the local community hears the evidence and must unanimously decide whether the state has proven guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. In a bench trial, there is no jury—a single judge hears the arguments and renders the verdict. Deciding between the two depends heavily on the specific facts of your case, the technical legal arguments involved, and the venue.
Can felony criminal charges in Missouri be dismissed before trial using pre-trial motions?
Yes, absolutely. A trial isn't always necessary to resolve a case favorably. By filing targeted pre-trial motions—such as motions to suppress illegally seized evidence or motions to dismiss based on statutory protections—we can present live witness testimony and legal arguments directly to the judge. If the court agrees that law enforcement violated your constitutional rights or that the law bars prosecution, the judge can dismiss the charges entirely before a jury is ever impaneled.
Why should I hire a criminal defense attorney with experience as a prosecutor and a public defender?
Having sat in every seat at the counsel table—as a judicial law clerk, public defender, and state prosecutor—gives an attorney a full 360-degree view of your case. Sam knows how prosecutors construct their charges, how judges evaluate legal arguments, and where the prosecution’s evidence is most vulnerable. That insight allows me to anticipate the state’s moves, negotiate from a position of strength, and build the strongest possible defense for you.
What steps can a defense lawyer take to get a felony charge reduced to a misdemeanor in Missouri?
Getting a felony reduced to a misdemeanor often comes down to aggressive preparation and showing the prosecutor the real weaknesses in their case. By thoroughly investigating the facts, challenging shaky witness statements, winning key pre-trial motions, or taking the case to trial to demonstrate that a jury won't convict on the felony, we create leverage. That leverage frequently forces the state to abandon felony charges in favor of a misdemeanor resolution.